Today we compare Purina Pro Plan vs Purina ONE. As a canine Nutritionist and pet owner, I have bought various types of foods for my dogs. My main concern was always how to provide my pets with the best nutrition.
I have researched these product lines in-depth to determine what sets them apart.
There are many factors to consider when choosing the best pet food brand for your pet:
- Ingredient quality,
- Guaranteed Analysis,
- Product safety,
- Cost
These are among the most important factors to consider.
While both product lines provide good overall nutritional value, the best brand for your dog will depend on your dog’s individual needs.
Let’s get started!
Purina Pro Plan Vs Purina ONE Introduction
When we have to decide between Purina Pro Plan vs Purina ONE, it can be a challenge for pet owners, but we will try to break that decision down and hopefully help you choose between the two.
Purina One is well known for its affordable yet high-quality products. They offer as a brand a vast number of different formulas to cater to the different needs of your pets. That means that whether you have a dog or a cat, rest assured there is a formula that fits its needs.
On the other hand, Purina Pro Plan is well known for its premium formulas. They concentrate on meeting your pet’s specific needs, so whether your pet requires special diets, or has intolerances, it is covered with a premium formula for Purina Pro Plan that is right for them.
Also, Purina Pro Plan offers a good variety of treats and supplements that help make your pet live a healthier and happy life.
Product Range Comparison
In this section, we will check the product ranges of both the Purina Pro Plan Vs Purina ONE brands
Purina Pro Plan
There are over 80 recipes to choose from in Purina Pro Plan, so there seems to be more variety. Each of them is targeted to cover a need or issue of your pet at any stage of its life.
Purina Pro Plan offers a formula range for Puppies, and small, medium, and large dogs.
Also, they have formulas specifically designed for
- Kidney function: this one is designed to help dogs who have compromised their kidney function and help regulate it.
- Urinary health: They also have another formula to help dissolve the struvite urinary calculi that can form in older dogs.
- Liver disease diet: this is a complete formula designed specifically for dealing with glucose regulation issues in your dog (diabetes mellitus)
- Arthritis diet: this formula is especially thought to prevent and manage joint problems in dogs of all ages.
- Hypoallergenic diet: this formula helps to manage food allergies in dogs of all ages.
- Cardioprotection diets: a formula created for adult dogs that helps the cardiac function and prevents the symptoms of cardiac-related problems from early stages.
- Brain and Cognitive function: this formula has been clinically tested to support a healthy cognitive function in senior dogs. They claim 30 days of visible results!
- Digestive health: This formula is created with easily digestible ingredients to help control gastrointestinal issues in dogs and puppies from 14 months of age.
- Probiotics for digestive issues: These supplements have been demonstrated to facilitate good digestive health and a balanced microflora in your dog’s intestine. This formula also contributes to maintaining a healthy immune system, and… dogs love it!!
- Convalescence: this formula is designed for all age dogs as nutritional support during their convalescence period.
- Skin Care: Purina Pro has a formula for supporting the dermic function in case of dermatitis or other skin issues, as well as excessive hair loss in dogs of all ages.
- Obesity: this formula is ideal for losing weight and maintaining an optimal one in adult dogs
Purina Pro Plan also offers Supplements and Probiotics to help support a healthy function and immune system in your furry best friend.
Purina ONE
Purina ONE offers various formulas for dogs in different life stages, such as puppies, adults, and seniors. It does not have as many formulas for different issues as the Purina Pro Plan, but it also caters to different needs. For instance, it has formulas for
Purina One is more of a budget option for the more conscious pet owners, as their products are generally less expensive.
Some reviews suggest that, despite the price, Purina ONE is not as quality effective as Purina Pro Plan at addressing some more specific health issues, as we can see above in the problems they both cover.
In this regard, Purina ONE is a good brand for pet owners looking to cover a wide variety of options for a less high price. Still, Purina Pro Plan is better at targeting particular issues as they have more specific formulas for particular needs.
Quality Comparison
In this section, we will analyze the quality of the product Purina Pro Plan vs Purina ONE by its first ingredients. How many questionable ingredients do both brands use?
Purina Pro Plan
When choosing dog food, it is essential to stop and have a look at how much quality and purity of ingredients there are. Unfortunately, Purina Pro Plan uses a few questionable ingredients in their recipes that may not be ideal for your pooch.
Unless it is stated that this particular recipe is made without these low-quality fillers or by-products, there is a good chance that it can contain some animal by-product that might not be as good for your dog´s health.
Although none of these ingredients or animal by-products are harmful in small quantities, and some even might help with minor issues, as a general rule, they should not be part of canine nutrition, especially nowadays, where there is plenty of high-quality food in the market to choose from.
Purina ONE
Purina ONE also uses questionable ingredients, like many other brands. Like the former, they also rely on cheaper fillers and animal by-products.
In addition, their products often contain added sugar and artificial additives to improve the flavor.
Nutritional value
Both of the products, Purina Pro Plan vs Purina ONE, have a variety of formulas to choose from, but, how does that compare when we are analyzing the overall nutritional value?
Both brand formulas meet AAFCO Guidelines for pet food.
Purina ONE
Purina ONE displays a dry matter protein reading of 30%, a fat level of 18%, and estimated carbohydrates of about 44%.
As a group, the brand features an average protein content of 30% and a mean fat level of 16%. Together, these figures suggest a carbohydrate content of 45% for the overall product line. And a fat-to-protein ratio of about 54%.
This means this Purina ONE product line contains…
Above-average protein. Near-average fat. And below-average carbs when compared to other dry dog foods.
However, when you consider the protein-boosting effect of the corn gluten and soybean meals and dried peas in this recipe and the inclusion of corn germ meal and soybean germ meal in other recipes, this looks like the profile of a kibble containing at least a moderate amount of meat.
Purina Pro Plan
Purina Pro Plan displays a dry matter protein reading of 30%, a fat level of 18%, and estimated carbohydrates of about 44%.
As a group, the brand features an average protein content of 31% and a mean fat level of 16%. Together, these figures suggest a carbohydrate content of 45% for the overall product line. And a fat-to-protein ratio of about 53%.
This means that this product line contains…
Above-average protein. Near-average fat. And below-average carbs when compared to other dry dog foods.
However, when you consider the protein-boosting effect of the soybean and corn gluten meals in this recipe, and the canola meal and pea protein contained in other recipes, this looks like the profile of a kibble containing just a moderate amount of meat.
When you compare Purina Pro Plan vs Purina ONE in terms of Nutritional Value, both brands have similar ratios in protein, carbs, and fat ratios. You can find a bit more protein in Purina ONE. However, Purina Pro seems to be a better choice due to the use of better ingredients than the former. Purina Pro is a better and healthier option.
Recalls and Product Safety
In this section, we will analyze the factors of the recalls of Purina Pro Plan Vs Purina ONE
There are three types:
- A firm takes actions to remove a product from the market- A voluntary recall (Recalls may be conducted on a firm’s initiative)
- FDA request,
- FDA order under statutory authority.
Purina Pro Plan
Here’s a list of all recalls since 2009 that are related to Purina dog products.
- Purina Recalls Pro Plan Vet Diet Product Due to Mislabeling (12/6/2022)
- Purina Beneful and Pro Plan Dog Food Recall (3/11/2016)
Purina ONE
The following automated list (if present) includes all dog food recalls related to Purina through January 2023.
- Purina One Beyond Dog Food Recall (8/30/2013)
You can search for a list of current FDA recalls here. Be sure to continue to track the recall status of any dog or cat food you consider to ensure that your pet’s diet is safe.
Overall Winner
Two of the most popular food brands in the market are Purina ONE and Purina Pro Plan, and sometimes it comes to a personal decision to choose between one of them. Both brands have a variety of formulas and recipes, and in general, most dogs will do well on both.
However, there are some differences that we have observed in Purina Pro Plan vs Purina ONE comparison.
In terms of prices, Purina Pro Plan vs Purina ONE, Purina ONE is the cheaper option, as it uses lesser quality ingredients than the Pro Plan formulas.
Purina Pro Plan is a better option to target a particular health issue, as it has more range of formulas.
Also, it has better quality regarding ingredients and nutritional value, so if the price is not an issue, Pro Plan is a better option to consider for your pup.
At last, if you are looking for the highest quality option, Pro Plan is your option, while if you are more on a budget, go with Purina ONE.
Whatever you decide, don´t forget to read the labels to do your research before considering any option.
What´s next?
If you enjoyed this article, you could check our reviews of the best dog food articles.
